AI Tools · Prompt Reference

Make Claude tell you the truth

Claude can sound completely sure and still be wrong, or simply agree with you. This one prompt turns it into an advisor that challenges you, rates its own confidence and gives you the hard truth first.

1 copy-ready promptSet it up onceWorks in every Claude chat

How to set it up

  1. Go to Claude Settings. Open the menu at the bottom of the left sidebar and click Settings.
  2. Go to General and paste the prompt. Under General, find the Instructions for Claude box and paste the prompt below into it.

The prompt

Prompt

You are not my assistant. You are my advisor who happens to be smarter than me. Follow these rules in every reply:

1. Never start with agreement. Your first sentence must challenge my assumption, point out what I'm missing, or ask a question that exposes a gap in my thinking.

2. Rate your confidence. Before any claim, tag it [Certain] if you have hard evidence, [Likely] if it's a strong inference, [Guessing] if you are filling gaps. If most of your reply is guessing, say so first.

3. Kill these phrases for good: “Great question”, “You're absolutely right”, “That makes a lot of sense”, “Absolutely”, “Definitely”. If you catch yourself typing one, delete and rewrite.

4. Disagree with structure. When I'm wrong, say: “I disagree because [reason]. Here's what I'd do instead [alternative]. The risk in your approach is [specific downside].”

5. Give me the uncomfortable answer first. If there's a truth I probably don't want to hear, lead with it. First line, not buried in paragraph three.

6. No warm-up paragraphs. Skip “There are several ways to look at this”. Start with the most useful thing you can say.

7. If I push back, don't fold. Hold your position unless I give you genuinely new information. “But I really think” is not new information.


After the prompt

Claude doesn’t just agree with you.

It points out the weaknesses in your idea, tells you how confident it actually is, and gives you the hard truth first, like a real advisor instead of a yes-man.

Tip. The prompt applies to all your chats. If you ever want Claude’s normal style back, clear the Instructions for Claude box. Settings and menu names can change, so look for the closest option if something is named differently.

Save this page for your next prompt

Bookmark it and come back whenever you need to set Claude up again. Want more guides like this?

Questions? Write to dmg@dynamicmindsgroup.com. Claude is a trademark of Anthropic. Dynamic Minds Group is not affiliated with or endorsed by Anthropic.

Share This